Coin and card collection worth $40,000 stolen during Lincoln break-in

A May break-in to a Lincoln man’s homes saw some very valuable collectible cards and coins stolden.

Alerted on May 21, Niagara Police responded to the break-in report and determined that sometime between May 10 and May 21, a suspect got into the home through a basement window.

They then stole a Sentry locked two-foot-by-two-foot safe, as well as a decorative box sitting on top of it.

Both the box and safe were jammed with collector coins, cash, and sports collector cards.   The thief also stole alcohol, frozen seafood, and a piece of Swiss Gear carry on luggage.

The owner puts the value of the stolen items at more than $40,000.  All stolen cards were stored in their own hard plastic card protector and in excellent condition.

Stolen collector cards include:

• Shaquille O’Neal NBA Hoops Card 1992-1993 “Magic’s all-rookie team card”
• Jaromir Jagr OPC Premiere Card 1990-1991 #50
• Wayne Gretzky OPC Premiere Card 1979
• Patrick Mahomes 2017 Panini Card 2017
• Jack Hughes Young Guns 2019
• Alex Ovechkin #443 2005
• Sydney Crosby #201 Young Guns 2005
• Patrick Roy OPC 1986-1987 #53 Hillcrest
• Mario Lemieux Hillcrest 1985-1986
• Connor McDavid 2015 Young Guns #201
• Leon Draisaitl Young Guns 2014 #223
• Jason Robertson Upper Deck 2020-2021 #235
• Austin Matthews Young Guns 2016 #201
• Mitch Marner 2016 Young Guns #468
• David Pastrnak 2014-2015 Young Guns
• Joe Montana Topps 1981 #216
• Tom Brady Rookie Card 2000 Bowman #236
• 1964 Topps Colour Full Set
• 1964 Diary Series Full Set colour

Stolen collectable coins and cash include:

• Canadian Silver Dollars complete set from 1950-1967 with 4 Different 1967 dollars (21 total coins)
• 8 Random Canadian Silver Dollars from 1950-1967
• Canadian Silver Dollar Maple leaf reverse 1948
• Canadian Silver Dollar Totem Pole 1958
• Canadian Silver Cameo 1958
• Canadian Quarters mixed 1950-1967 – 209 of these quarters
• Canadian $.50 coins 1950-1967 Complete series some doubles – 32 coins in total
• 2.3 ounces of broken gold from broken necklaces, bracelets and rings
• Canadian $1 Bill 1954 “Devil Faces” – 3 of these
• Canadian $5 Bill 1954 – 3 of these
• Canadian $10 Bill 1954 – 2 of these
• Canadian $50 Bill 1954 – 2 of these
• Canadian $100 Bill 1954 – 1 of these
• American Silver Dollar 1987 – 2 of these
• American “Morgan” Silver Dollars – 2 of these
• American Silver Dollar 1999 – 1 of these

Retail and private collectors are asked to report any recent suspicious attempted sales of collectable cards, coins or cash.

Anyone with information about this crime is asked to contact the investigating officer by calling 905-688-4111, option 3, 1009588.